Why catchment areas give the illusion of choice

If you have a child in Y6 then you're probably going through one of the most stressful times of their school life: the battle for a place at a decent secondary. Suddenly parents you've known for years will become slightly shifty whenever the conversation turns to 'which schools have you put down?' and getting your hands on a full set of practice papers requires skill and cunning. (And if they're trying for a place at a grammar or private school, their offspring will be being tutored to within an inch of their lives.)

There's been a lot of talk this week (mostly from politicians who probably send their kids to the best private schools anyway) about punishing parents who lie about where they live to win school places. This kind of thing is particularly rife in our borough, where despite the rapidly growing population there hasn't been a decent non-faith state school built for over 18 years (but countless luxury flats, many still unsold). Not surprisingly competition for places is fierce. I know of parents who have swapped houses, and others who have rented to be within the catchment area (0.5miles!) of the best comprehensive school.

The point is that catchment areas create the illusion of choice where there isn't one, because some parents always know how to play the system and those who can afford to move closer to the school will always do so, pushing the prices up and forcing the less well off out.

In my opinion, all kids leaving primary school should have the option of a place at a fantastic secondary school within reasonable walking distance of their home and without having to pass an academic exam to get into it.

Prosecuting parents who lie about where they live because they want the best for their children isn't going to solve the problem. Building new schools will.

Currently rated 5.0 by 9 people

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Bookmark and Share

Comments

Leave a comment

 
This will not be displayed
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading

About LivingwithKids

Living with Kids is a family blog from KidStart where Liz Jarvis will share stories, thoughts and expert tips, and she'll also tell you about the best family holidays, days out, offers and products for you and your kids. More...

Introducing Liz

I'm a mum and freelance journalist who writes for some of the UK's top parenting magazines and websites. My family is my whole world - but they can drive me crazy, too! More...

Recent Comments

Comment RSS

Sainsbury's Little Ones baby & toddler club

Sainsbury's Little Ones baby & toddler club

Top Toy Reviews

1. Lego City Fire Helicopter
"Ben loved this great..." read more

2. Ezy Roller
"Great fun and good..." read more

3. Baby Whoozit
"Bright colours and..." read more

4. Solar Butterfly
"A simple idea..." read more

5. Dream Town Rose Petal Cottage Playhouse
"Adorable playhouse..." read more

>>Read All our Toy Reviews

Nanny McPhee

Quick Links

Recommended Reads
Book reviews for kids, teens and you reviewed by real Mums and their kids.

Panel of Experts
Ask the LivingwithKids panel of experts on topics ranging from family health and child safety to money saving tips  

The Mum Test
Read the product reviews of our Mum's and tots from pushchairs to toys

Facebook
Become a fan of LivingwithKids

Twitter
Follow Livingwithkids on Twitter


This is a Tots 100 blog

Awards

The MADS

I Love your Blog

Sunshine Blog Award